Is there probs with Netmeeting and ICS ?

Is there probs with Netmeeting and ICS ?

Post by Stuart Macki » Thu, 13 Dec 2001 07:51:49



My friend is in a house where 5 of them share an ADSL line.  He is a client
on their internal network which is connected to the ADSL line through ICS
and someone elses PC.  He had tried Netmeeting to talk with family and he
can see and hear them but they can't see or hear him.  On looking on the
Support site there is a KB article stating that Netmeeting may not work over
ICS.

Can anyone suggest what may be wrong, or if there is a definite problem with
Netmeeting and ICS ?

Thanks for any help,
Stuart.

 
 
 

Is there probs with Netmeeting and ICS ?

Post by Brian Sullivan -MV » Thu, 13 Dec 2001 08:14:33



Quote:> My friend is in a house where 5 of them share an ADSL line.  He is a
client
> on their internal network which is connected to the ADSL line through ICS
> and someone elses PC.  He had tried Netmeeting to talk with family and he
> can see and hear them but they can't see or hear him.  On looking on the
> Support site there is a KB article stating that Netmeeting may not work
over
> ICS.

> Can anyone suggest what may be wrong, or if there is a definite problem
with
> Netmeeting and ICS ?

There is a potential problem -- ICS is a NAT -- NAT does not work with H.323
unless the NAT has special H.323 handling ( it exhibits the symptoms you
mention). There is is some speculation that ICS on some platforms ( it seems
it is different on every platform) is supposed to have this support -- I
have never been able to get any official confirmation ( nor denial) that
this is the case.

It may all be for nought though as the DSL modem may be a NAT as well  -
even if ICS had the required H.323 support it may be subverted by the
"modem".

 
 
 

Is there probs with Netmeeting and ICS ?

Post by Stuart Macki » Thu, 13 Dec 2001 08:20:38


Ok.  I've tried to find out about the ADSL line and most peeps have said it
is non-NAT and its the ICS thats cuasing a problem.  A few said it is NAT
but on looking at a very white papers for UK ADSL it appears that a Packet
forwarding system is used rather than NAT

So overally it seems as though its ICS causing the problem.  If you ever
hear of a fix please let me know :o)

Thanks,
Stuart.





> > My friend is in a house where 5 of them share an ADSL line.  He is a
> client
> > on their internal network which is connected to the ADSL line through
ICS
> > and someone elses PC.  He had tried Netmeeting to talk with family and
he
> > can see and hear them but they can't see or hear him.  On looking on the
> > Support site there is a KB article stating that Netmeeting may not work
> over
> > ICS.

> > Can anyone suggest what may be wrong, or if there is a definite problem
> with
> > Netmeeting and ICS ?

> There is a potential problem -- ICS is a NAT -- NAT does not work with
H.323
> unless the NAT has special H.323 handling ( it exhibits the symptoms you
> mention). There is is some speculation that ICS on some platforms ( it
seems
> it is different on every platform) is supposed to have this support -- I
> have never been able to get any official confirmation ( nor denial) that
> this is the case.

> It may all be for nought though as the DSL modem may be a NAT as well  -
> even if ICS had the required H.323 support it may be subverted by the
> "modem".

 
 
 

1. Netmeeting ands several participants

Hi
I am new to this group so sorry if I am asking an old question How does one
go about configuring Netmeeting to allow more than one video connection

I am trying to set up a conference with 3 or max 4 persons how do we do this

When I try with one person no problem but when i try with two nothing at all
no audio no video

Help

Thanks for an answer here or to my email


Mats

-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----==  Over 80,000 Newsgroups - 16 Different Servers! =-----

2. Intel CD-ROM and Tape Drive questions

3. MSN V2 (UK) ands Internet Mail

4. IBM PSP Operating System Strategy

5. I am not receiving mail and am unable to send mail,

6. Notes as a software distrinution platform?

7. ICS and Netmeeting

8. ovrdbf question

9. Netmeeting ICS Win2K

10. How to setup Netmeeting behind Win2000 Internet Connection Sharing(ICS)

11. Netmeeting with ICS: What ports to be forwarded?

12. Netmeeting/ICS/Windows 2000 And Dialup Settings

13. ICS and netmeeting