Second call for vote for comp.graphics.avs

Second call for vote for comp.graphics.avs

Post by David Benne » Thu, 26 Sep 1991 04:01:31



This is the second Call for Votes for the creation of the newsgroup
comp.graphics.avs

Posting began on September 12, 1991 and will continue for 21 days until
October 3, 1991 at midnight EST.

The results of the first week ( until Sept 19, 1991 at 11:30) are posted
alphabetically at the end of this file so you may verify your vote.

If you have not voted yet:

The proposed group is described as follows:

_________________________________________________________________

NAME:
        comp.graphics.avs

STATUS:

        unmoderated

CHARTER:

        This newsgroup is a forum for the discussion of AVS (Application
        Visualization System) related subjects.  Other items include how
        to obtain modules, documentation and sample data sets from the
        International AVS Center located at the North Carolina Supercomputing
        Center, how to submit modules for sharing with others, interactive
        communication between users, notice of new developments in AVS
        and a catalyst for creating collaborations between groups
        or individuals working on similar projects.  The newsgroup will serve as
        a forum for information exchange on AVS (the product) including
        standards (as they relate to AVS), discussions on needed features,
        helpful techniques, etc.  The Center will also coordinate AVS User
        Groups, newsletters, catalogs, create an AVS Showroom and provide
        AVS training.  The International AVS Center is supported by the AVS
        Consortium that is made up of CONVEX, DEC, Evans and Sutherland, HP,
        IBM, SET Technologies and Stardent with porting of AVS also coordinated
        with Sun, Cray, FPS, SGI and Wave Tracer. The Center is vendor neutral.

        The International AVS Center will help support the
        newsgroup by reading submissions and offering assistance as needed.

        NCSC is a non-profit organization specializing in networking, mass
        storage, distributed visualization with a focus on AVS and technology
        transfer.  The infrastructure that is in place in North Carolina is
        basically a mini-NREN and as such is an ideal place to test emerging
        technologies.  It is the intention of the International AVS Center
        to take AVS beyond the "scientific visualization" platform that it
        currently supports and add many new services and increase functionality.

NAME SELECTION:

        Many names were discussed and it was felt that this newsgroup did
        not fit into any predefined category since it dealt with so many
        AVS specific issues.  The initial AVS user base is over 1,500 people
        and expected to double this year.  It did not fit as comp.sys.avs,
        etc, and after some begging and pleading we could not get
        the support for comp.avs.  The newsgroup will deal with hardware
        issues, software issues, user issues, new developments and information
        exchange.  The name comp.graphics.avs was considered closest to
        focus and would also allow room for the future shaping of AVS.

VOTING PROCEDURE:

        Mail your vote to one of the following addresses as appropriate:

        YES votes:      yes...@ncsc.org
        NO  votes:      no...@ncsc.org
        Correction:     oops...@ncsc.org

        DO NOT POST YOUR VOTE TO THE NET!! - ANY SUCH VOTE WILL BE IGNORED!!
        Only votes mailed to the vote-taker addresses listed above will count.
        Proxy votes will not be counted

        Your vote will be processed automatically, and only the destination
        of your vote will be taken into the final accounting.  However, votes
        must be EXPLICIT.  They should take the form of "I vote for the
        group comp.graphics.avs as proposed" or "I vote against the group
        comp.graphics.avs as proposed".  The wording does not have to be
        exact, it just needs to be unambiguous.  In particular, statements of
        the form " I would vote for this group if ..." should be considered
        comments only and not counted as votes.

        If for some reason, you sent your vote to the wrong address, send
        mail to Correction ( opps...@ncsc.org).  This mail is processed
        manually, so please be explicit about your new vote.  If you do have
        comments about the International AVS Center or this newsgroup, please
        address them to a...@ncsc.org or mail to The International AVS Center,
        P.O. Box 12889, 3021 Cornwallis Road, RTP, NC 27713.

DEADLINE:

        All votes must be received by 11:59 PM EST ( GMT - 07:00),
        October 3, 1991.  A sorted list of voters will be posted
        each Friday beginning September 20, 1991 so that you may verify
        that your vote has been received.  The full results will be
        posted one day after the deadline of October 3, 1991 along
        with a breakdown of the votes received.  There will then be a
        five day waiting period during which the net will have a chance
        to correct any errors in the voter list or the voting procedure.

COMMENTS:

        The protocol for creating a newsgroup requires that there be
        100 more YES votes than NO votes, and that at least 2/3 of the
        valid votes be YES votes.

__________________________________________________________________________

David Bennett, NCSC, RTP, NC 27709
AVS Project Leader
Visualization/Collaboratory Group
phone: (919) 248-1182
email dav...@ncsc.org
AVS email a...@ncsc.org

*************************************************************************
The NO votes were:

From: a...@cblph.att.com (Arthur S Kamlet)
From: c...@chinacat.unicom.com (Chip Rosenthal)
From: c...@tct.com (Chip Salzenberg)
From: guen...@prism.gatech.edu (Brian Guenter)
From: hsm...@imagine.convex.com (Henry Smith)
From: Kjetil Wiekhorst J|rgensen <jorg...@lise.unit.no>
From: ke...@juts.ccc.amdahl.com (Kim DeVaughn)
From: koz...@ncsa.uiuc.edu (Quincey Koziol)
From: lini...@nominil.lonestar.org (Mark Linimon)
From: mur...@vs6.scri.fsu.edu (John Murray)
From: Rich Thomson <rthom...@dsd.es.com>
From: t...@dretor.dciem.dnd.ca (Tim Pointing)
From: "Todd L. Masco" <tm...@andrew.cmu.edu>
***************************************************************************

The YES votes were:

From: Alan B Clegg <a...@concert.net>
From: acal...@hubcap.clemson.edu (Alan C. Calder)
From: Alan Blatecky <al...@concert.net>
From: Anay S. Panvalkar <a...@mcnc.org>
From: Arturo Puente <art...@Neon.Stanford.EDU>
From: au...@starman.convex.com (John David Auwen)
From: bal...@osiris.rti.org (Lisa M. Balbes)
From: bcalv...@cadsun.corp.mot.com (Brian Calvert)
From: birds...@swatc1.convex.com (Jay Birdsong)
From: bot...@mikey.convex.com (Mark Botner)
From: Jim Brooking <brook...@ncsc.org>
From: b...@starman.convex.com (Andrew Bros)
From: Bruce Loftis <br...@ncsc.org>
From: br...@neit.cgd.ucar.EDU (Frank Bryan)
From: b...@rcdips.nrl.navy.mil (Buck Buchanan)
From: bwo...@starman.convex.com (Bruce Wolfe)
From: Carson R. Stuart <car...@mcnc.org>
From: cass...@ncsc.org (Peter Cassels)
From: chal...@det.dec.com (George Chaltas)
From: char...@convex1.convex.com (Dave Charles)
From: "Bill Clifford, ZKO2-2/O23, dtn:381-2268" <cliff...@dssdev.enet.dec.com>
From: cl...@allen.com (Cliff Allen)
From: "Al Shpuntoff" <cs...@zeus.unomaha.edu>
From: cur...@mozart.convex.com (Austin Curley)
From: Dan Winkelstein <d...@concert.net>
From: da...@c1apple.convex.com (Dave Dorfman)
From: David Kamins <da...@Stardent.COM>
From: da...@hydra.convex.com (Dave Mullally)
From: dav...@ncsc.org (David Bennett)
From: Dave Bock <dbock@doppler>
From: James Krack "denver::mrgate::"a1::krack.james""@denver.enet.dec.com
From: d...@Stardent.COM (Daniel K. Edwin)
From: dor...@hydra.convex.com (Nancy Dorsey)
From: dout...@starman.convex.com (Ronnie Douthit)
From: Dana Roode <DRo...@uci.edu>
From: drw...@anusf.anu.edu.au ("Drew R Whitehouse")
From: Donald Yett <dy...@phad.hsc.usc.edu>
From: er...@comet.convex.com (Daniel Ernst)
From: f...@mr.picker.com (fares hajjer)
From: "Jim Flatten, Graphics Product Manager, <flat...@dssdev.enet.dec.com>
From: frank...@imagine.convex.com (Rick Franklin)
From: fra...@stardent.COM (Bob Fraser)
From: fraz...@hooker.convex.com (Robert Frazier)
From: Bill Fuller <ful...@mcnc.org>
From: gard...@imagine.convex.com (Steve Gardner)
From: Michael Good  17-Sep-1991 1056 <g...@pipe.enet.dec.com>
From: DIGITALy <gro...@canova.enet.dec.com> (Roberto Grossi)
From: gusta...@pixel.convex.com (Duane Gustavus)
From: hall...@convex1.convex.com (Deborah Hallett)
From: hen...@orion.convex.com.convex.com (Don Hender)
From: hmitc...@vlasov.gsfc.nasa.gov (Horace G. Mitchell)
From: h...@pixel.convex.com (David Holt)
From: hors...@starman.convex.com (Steve Horsmon)
From: Heinrich Schnermann <h...@influx.sub.org>
From: Jeffrey C. Huskamp <husk...@ncsc.org>
From: jeffr...@ncsa.uiuc.edu (Jeffrey Thingvold -Visualization)
From: jgr...@muse.convex.com (J L Greathouse)
From: j...@msc.edu (Joel Neisen)
From: jo...@mozart.convex.com (Joel Williamson)
From: jor...@cs.rpi.edu (Joaquim Jorge)
From: Jim Lick <j...@piggy.ucsb.edu>
From: <j...@geoblue.gcn.uoknor.edu> (Jay Liang)
From: j...@stardent.COM (Joe Leonard)
From: Joe Ragland - CONCERT Network NOC <j...@concert.net>
From: jsi...@mikey.convex.com (Josh Simon)
From: Kathy E. Yount <k...@mcnc.org>
From: khar...@pixel.convex.com (Kathy Harris)
From: Jeff Knerr <kn...@ncsc.org>
From: Kris Allsbury <k...@ncsc.org>
From: lamb...@convex1.convex.com (Paul Lambert)
From: lave...@bach.convex.com (Brent LaVelle)
From: Linda B. Smith <l...@mcnc.org>
From: uunet.UU.NET!lhdsy1!drj (Dave R. Jones)
From: l...@mozart.convex.com (Ron Lieberman)
From: lind...@hydra.convex.com (Norman Lindsey)
From: loren...@dwaskill.crd.ge.com (william e lorensen)
From: Mike Pentimone <m...@ncsc.org>
From: Marcie Armstrong <mar...@ncsc.org>
From: maza...@orion.convex.com.convex.com (Robert Mazanec)
From: mce...@aspen.convex.com (Bill McEwin)
From: md...@bach.convex.com (Matthew Diaz)
From: Urs Meyer <me...@ifi.unizh.ch>
From: mel...@muse.convex.com (Mike Melton)
From: Thomas David Mills <mi...@mcnc.org>
From: mu...@mikey.convex.com (Ernst Mutke)
From: Nadine_Leend...@mts.ucs.ualberta.ca
From: Jorgen Moth <NEUJM%vm.uni-c...@SEARN.SUNET.SE>
From: no...@dhostwo.convex.com (Suzan Dry Noden)
From: opped...@magnum.convex.com (Doug Oppedahl)
From: Chris Parra <pa...@concert.net>
From: p...@jaameri.gsfc.nasa.gov (Patrick M. Ryan)
From: Pat Richardson <patr...@concert.net>
From: patr...@mozart.convex.com (Patrick F. McGehearty)
From: pb...@mikey.convex.com ( Phil Barr)
From: Paul Jensen <p...@bilbo.Colorado.EDU>
From: pe...@alamos.enet.dec.com ( Bob Peach)
From: peop...@convex1.convex.com (Alison Peoples)
From: pet...@mikey.convex.com (James Peters)
From: Debra Pheris Blencowe <phe...@convext.convex.com>
From: Paul Higgins <phigg...@uci.edu>
From: phill...@acs.ucalgary.ca (Doug S. Phillips)
From: Lisa C. Pickel <pic...@mcnc.org>
From: John Hancock <q...@ncsc.org>
From: Ray Idaszak <rayi@doppler>
From: r...@sunpix.East.Sun.COM (Reid Judd - Sun Visualization Products)
From: reut...@iris.eecs.ucdavis.edu (Bryan Reutter)
From: rfi...@water.ca.gov (Ralph Finch)
From: William R. Richards Jr. <richa...@mcnc.org>
From: "Ray Masters 814-865-0828" <R...@PSUVM.PSU.EDU>
From: rkr...@dsd.es.com (Randall Krebs)
From: r...@tip.wedge.nt.com (Robert L. Smith)
From: rol...@convex1.convex.com (Richard Roloff)
From: r...@monu6.cc.monash.edu.au (Ron Van Schyndel)
From: rothe...@aspen.convex.com (Dave Rotheroe)
From: roys...@unccvax.uncc.edu (David Royster)
From: rpe...@convex1.convex.com (Dick Perry)
From: rsign...@crusty.er.usgs.gov (Richard P. Signell)
From: r...@magnum.convex.com (Russell E. Donnan)
From: Sandy Brown <san...@ncsc.org>
From: "Allen V. R. Schiano" <schi...@uci.edu>
From: schum...@starman.convex.com (Richard A. Schumacher)
From: Julie Sellers <sell...@concert.net>
From: sflei...@hydra.convex.com (Steve Fleischman)
From: shan...@neptune.convex.com (Stewart Shankel)
From: s...@sequoia.cray.com (Sharan Kalwani)
From: Rodney Shojinaga <shjn...@ncsc.org>
From: s...@convext.convex.com (Mark Shoemaker)
From: smi...@hydra.convex.com (Murray Smigel)
From: sow...@rigel.convex.com (Robin Sowton)
From: Jeffrey S. Jewett <SPI...@UMD2.UMD.EDU>
From: sp...@trojan.convex.com (Rob Spray)
From: srogers%...@uunet.UU.NET (Steve Rogers)
From: ssm...@ringer.cs.utsa.edu (Sammie L. Smith)
From: Susan Stearman <stear...@mavin.enet.dec.com>
From: st...@hubcap.clemson.edu ("Steve" Stevenson)
From: shankar n swamy <swa...@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu>
From: swar...@neptune.convex.com (Steve Warren)
From: ta...@bu-pub.bu.edu
From: Dorota Temple <tem...@mcnc.org>
From: "Tim O. Robinson" <ti...@hydrogen.cchem.berkeley.edu>
From: Tom Sandoski <t...@concert.net>
From: t...@mozart.convex.com (Bill Torkelson)
From: "Lance's Account" <tr...@prwnkl.enet.dec.com>(Lance Tribe)
From: Leila Tvedt Hyde <tv...@mcnc.org>
From: Vicki Rothe <vro...@ncsc.org>
From: wen...@sol.bucknell.edu (wenner - 1266)
From: ewbet...@lbl.gov (Wes Bethel )
From: Jonathan Whaley <wha...@ncsc.org>
From: wh...@capstan.convex.com (Tom White)
From: Gordon Whittenx890 <whit...@mcnc.org>
From: Lyle Wiedeman <wiede...@uci.edu>
From: William James Farlow <w...@mcnc.org>
From: wo...@bdrc.bd.com (Woody Muller)
From: wsm...@imagine.convex.com (Wade Smith)
From: Yee-Hsiang Chang <y...@concert.net>
From: zab...@flare.convex.com (Frank Zabaly)