ordb - open relay

ordb - open relay

Post by Drew McBe » Sat, 03 Aug 2002 00:36:23



    I just set up a 'new' email server - RH 7.3 2.4.18-3 . Quad cpu, 10 scsi
drives  w/sotware raid, 512 meg ram. I've got i nic w/a public ip address,
and the email server sits behind a linux firewall running RH7.3 2.4.28-3
with iptables.

    I submitted my ip to ORDB for on open relay test, and they told me a had
an open relay. I use Sendmail and Sophos MailMonitor. Mail monitor recieves
the mail at port 25, scans it, and sends it on to Sendmail at port 2525.
Mail monitor has some features with restrict/allow clients, but I'm more
concerned with Sendmail. as far as I know, theres only one file to
allow/disallow relaying and that is /etc/mail/access, and I allow it from
localhost.localdomain , localhost, and 127.0.0.1 only.

    My question is: Is it problem having those things ( localhost, etc. )
open?? Is there another place that I could leave a relay open ( other than
MailMonitor -just focusing on Sendmail right now)? Could there be a iptables
rules issue ( I don't think so.. ) ? ALSO - Is ORDBs known for being 100%
reliable???

                        Thanks -
                                        Drew M

--

_____________________

Drew McBee
Network Technician
Tradesmen International
6830 Cochran Rd.
Solon, OH 44139
1-440-996-3141 direct line
1-440-349-3432 x2141
1-800-573-0850 x2141

www.tradesmeninternational.com

 
 
 

ordb - open relay

Post by Whoeve » Sat, 03 Aug 2002 02:57:32



>     I just set up a 'new' email server - RH 7.3 2.4.18-3 . Quad cpu, 10 scsi
> drives  w/sotware raid, 512 meg ram. I've got i nic w/a public ip address,
> and the email server sits behind a linux firewall running RH7.3 2.4.28-3
> with iptables.

>     I submitted my ip to ORDB for on open relay test, and they told me a had
> an open relay. I use Sendmail and Sophos MailMonitor. Mail monitor recieves
> the mail at port 25, scans it, and sends it on to Sendmail at port 2525.
> Mail monitor has some features with restrict/allow clients, but I'm more
> concerned with Sendmail. as far as I know, theres only one file to
> allow/disallow relaying and that is /etc/mail/access, and I allow it from
> localhost.localdomain , localhost, and 127.0.0.1 only.

>     My question is: Is it problem having those things ( localhost, etc. )
> open?? Is there another place that I could leave a relay open ( other than
> MailMonitor -just focusing on Sendmail right now)? Could there be a iptables
> rules issue ( I don't think so.. ) ? ALSO - Is ORDBs known for being 100%
> reliable???

AFAIK, ORDB is reliable. If you are not convinced, do a "database lookup"
on their website and they will display an email that was relayed.

Your problem is probably not with Sendmail. Sendmail will see any email
that comes from MailMonitor as coming from the local loopback (127.0.0.1)
and thus will allow it. While you continue to use MailMonitor to receive
email, I don't think there  is much you can do about this.

You need to look at the configuration of MailMonitor -- it has to reject
the relay attempts because, in your configuration, Sendmail cannot
distinguish between relay attempts and email that originated from inside
your network. Rmemeber that it is trivial to forge the "from" address in a
relay attempt.

 
 
 

1. ordb open relay

I just set up a 'new' email server - RH 7.3 2.4.18-3 . Quad cpu, 10 scsi
drives  w/sotware raid, 512 meg ram. I've got i nic w/a public ip address,
and the email server sits behind a linux firewall running RH7.3 2.4.28-3
with iptables.

    I submitted my ip to ORDB for on open relay test, and they told me a had
an open relay. I use Sendmail and Sophos MailMonitor. Mail monitor recieves
the mail at port 25, scans it, and sends it on to Sendmail at port 2525.
Mail monitor has some features with restrict/allow clients, but I'm more
concerned with Sendmail. as far as I know, theres only one file to
allow/disallow relaying and that is /etc/mail/access, and I allow it from
localhost.localdomain , localhost, and 127.0.0.1 only.

    My question is: Is it problem having those things ( localhost, etc. )
open?? Is there another place that I could leave a relay open ( other than
MailMonitor -just focusing on Sendmail right now)? Could there be a iptables
rules issue ( I don't think so.. ) ? ALSO - Is ORDBs known for being 100%
reliable???

                        Thanks -
                                        Drew M

--

_____________________

Drew McBee
Network Technician
Tradesmen International
6830 Cochran Rd.
Solon, OH 44139
1-440-996-3141 direct line
1-440-349-3432 x2141
1-800-573-0850 x2141

www.tradesmeninternational.com

2. 570f RS/6000

3. postfix: relay domains and open relay

4. HELP: HelixGnome Install on Slack 7.1

5. How do I change sendmail from open relay to closed relay?

6. Please help with vmode problems!

7. Bad Sendmails with otherwise good OSes, Re: Open relays on DNS

8. Z-modem download from host?

9. qmail open relay

10. REPOST: Re: Have there been any full surveys of open relays?

11. Open relay or not?

12. In solaris 8, is sendmail relay function open by default?

13. smtp "open" relaying?