It's a religious war....

It's a religious war....

Post by John Winte » Sun, 15 Dec 1996 04:00:00






>> I don't know who originally said this but their head is in the sand.
>> Linux is becoming huge in the business world (check out the adds in the latest
>> Linux Journal). Here is an excerpt from the latest WGS linux news letter:

>> At Comdex/96, North America's largest computer trade show, WGS offered
>> a FREE Pentium computer to people for filling out a survey.  One of the
>> survey questions was "Do you use Linux  Yes / No".  There was absolutely
>> no reason why people would lie on it as they could win either way.  Our
>> preliminary count is that over 45% of the respondents said yes!  We got
>> enough surveys filled out for statistical accuracy at the 250,000 attendee
>> show.

>> -- wayne
>> Wayne O. Cochran   Graduate Student - Computer Science

>> web:http://www.eecs.wsu.edu/~wcochran
>> School of EE/CS  Washington State University   Ecclesiastes 12:12

>If most of the respondents were just choosing answers at random,
>then you would expect about 50% to say "yes".  How do you know
>this isn't what happened? The fact that 45% said "yes" means nothing
>without more data.

OTOH, you have no reason to believe that the respondents were answering
at random.  That hypothesis is less likely than the more obvious one.
It would be very difficult to hit upon a random cross section of the
delegates who behaved like that.

What might skew the figures could be the way the sample was taken.  If,
for example, the questionnaire was given to people who came to some sort
of Linux stand, then it could potentially be a most un-representative
sample.  If the figure is 45% of "people who expressed a general interest
in Linux", then it is probably pretty meaningless.  If OTOH it was
a genuinely random sample of those attending, and they were presented
with the survey under no specific OS heading (I.e. it wasn't portrayed
as "A survey of Linux usage", but merely as a general gathering of
information) then the 45% figure could be deeply significant.

John

(Newsgroups heavily trimmed.  Follow-ups trimmed even more.)
--
John Winters.  Wallingford, Oxon, England.

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Danette & Murray Ro » Mon, 16 Dec 1996 04:00:00



comp.lang.c:

=>OTOH, you have no reason to believe that the respondents were answering
=>at random.  That hypothesis is less likely than the more obvious one.
=>It would be very difficult to hit upon a random cross section of the
=>delegates who behaved like that.

=>What might skew the figures could be the way the sample was taken.  If,
=>for example, the questionnaire was given to people who came to some sort
=>of Linux stand, then it could potentially be a most un-representative
=>sample.  If the figure is 45% of "people who expressed a general interest

It's an un-representative sample because it was taken at COMDEX. While some
non-'computer geeks' attend, they number only a small fraction of the total.
Taking a survey at ANY trade show is significant only within that trade. The
original issue was 'Joe Sixpack' - specifically, the very people who DON'T go
to COMDEX.

When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.
For business - Unix over linux because legal wants someone thay can sue.

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

Amaze Your Friends! Confound Your Neighbors! Stupefy Your Enemies!

THINK!

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Paul Bransto » Tue, 17 Dec 1996 04:00:00


Quote:> When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
> linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.

I agree with this, Linux needs to be easier.

Quote:> For business - Unix over linux because legal wants someone thay can sue.

Have you looked at most software contracts, they specifically exclude
fitness for purpose, we can't get a supplier to agree to inlcuding this.
Then try to sue.  The best you can due is pay in tranches and if it
fails to live up to spec refuse to pay the rest and let them take you to
 court.

Paul.

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Mats Andtbac » Tue, 17 Dec 1996 04:00:00



Quote:>> When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
>> linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.
>I agree with this, Linux needs to be easier.

i disagree vehemently.

Linux doesn't *need* to be anything, apart from enough much fun for
the developers to keep hacking on it.

Linux didn't get to where it is by being easy, for newbies or anybody
else. it didn't become what it is by doing anything that wasn't
already done by some other OS, or indeed anything in particular at
all. we got to where we are because a lot of people thought building a
freeware OS was enough interesting and enough *fun* for them to bother
doing it.

the fact that some people - as far as i can tell, earnestly - want
Linux to take over the world, is in my eyes *wrong*. it's ass-
backwards, it's not what Linux is about.

by extension, i would say we don't need fancy GUIs and point-and-click
installation procedures. we don't need to convince people to use
Linux, we don't need market shares. commercial software might be
interesting, but only useful to Linux as a whole insofar as it's fun
value exceeds its monetary cost.
--
        "...Everybody got this broken feeling
         like their father or their dog just died..."
                                                        - Leonard Cohen

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by david parso » Tue, 17 Dec 1996 04:00:00




Quote:>> When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
>> linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.

>I agree with this, Linux needs to be easier.

  It depends on the installation.  McAfee's WebShield, which currently
  only runs on a hardened Linux kernel, has a pretty much fire and
  forget installation; you plug in the boot floppy and CD, turn the
  machine on, answer yes to a small collection of networking questions,
  and poof you've got a working enterprise antivirus solution.

                ____

                 \/

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Darin Johns » Tue, 17 Dec 1996 04:00:00


Quote:>It's an un-representative sample because it was taken at COMDEX. While some
>non-'computer geeks' attend, they number only a small fraction of the total.
>Taking a survey at ANY trade show is significant only within that trade. The
>original issue was 'Joe Sixpack' - specifically, the very people who DON'T go
>to COMDEX.

Oh?  I had always assumed the non-technical people went to COMDEX.
Salespeople, managers, and so forth.  After all technical people aren't
important enough to send to some trade show.  

--
Darin Johnson

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Incon » Thu, 19 Dec 1996 04:00:00




->>When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
->> linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.
->
->I agree with this, Linux needs to be easier.

It's called "RedHat 4.0".  Get it.

->> For business - Unix over linux because legal wants someone thay can sue.
->
->Have you looked at most software contracts, they specifically exclude
->fitness for purpose, we can't get a supplier to agree to inlcuding this.
->Then try to sue.  The best you can due is pay in tranches and if it
->fails to live up to spec refuse to pay the rest and let them take you to
->court.

True, but the original poster is correct:  the legal and business people
like to buy software because they don't trust freeware.
--
Craig Kelley --  "Beware the dark chocolate."  Forrest Yoda

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Bob Nels » Sat, 21 Dec 1996 04:00:00





> >For those of us who make our living writing business software Linux is, and
> >shall remain, an interesting something to play with when there is some spare
> >time. Windows 95 and Windows NT, on the other hand, is what there is, the
> >platform wheron we find our daily bread.
> I see. So Solaris, HP-UX, SCO and all those other things are also
> hobbyist/academic jewels.

Lord/Allah/M/M. O'Hare only knows why (and how) comp.lang.c was ever
unfortunate enough to be included in the newsgroups for this topic.
However, since it is -- and realizing that there are some Linux
partisans (Kaz among them) in the c.l.c. regulars...

...here's yet another (surprising?) place where you'll find an instance
of undefined behavior. Check out the hexify.c file from the
"arch/i386/kernel" directory. In the 2.0.23 kernel release, one will
find the following (which gives rise to the rumor that Schildt and
Torvalds have formed an unholy alliance):

------------------------------------------------------------------------

#include <stdio.h>

void main()
{
        int c;
        int comma=0;
        int count=0;
        while((c=getchar())!=EOF)
        {
                unsigned char x=c;
                if(comma)
                        printf(",");
                else
                        comma=1;
                if(count==8)
                {
                        count=0;
                        printf("\n");
                }
                if(count==0)
                        printf("\t");
                printf("0x%02X",c);
                count++;
        }
        if(count)
                printf("\n");
        exit(0);

Quote:}

------------------------------------------------------------------------

void main, it's not just for DOS anymore. (Of course, there are a few
other things suspect in this code, too.)

--
=============================================================================

     linux for fun, M$ for $$$...and the NFL for what really counts!
=============================================================================

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by William McBri » Mon, 23 Dec 1996 04:00:00


:   It depends on the installation.  McAfee's WebShield, which currently
:   only runs on a hardened Linux kernel, has a pretty much fire and
                 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
A what?

--
William McBrine    | http://www.clark.net/pub/wmcbrine/html/

 
 
 

It's a religious war....

Post by Douglas E Forbu » Fri, 27 Dec 1996 04:00:00


: > When someone comes up with a 'insert CD, click Install' method of installing
: > linux, it may become a 'masses' OS. Until then, we're stuck with MS.
:
: I agree with this, Linux needs to be easier.

Well look at the newest Redhat cd's..  What could be simpler than that!?
Woop, no clicking though, someone actually has to type in the word "REDHAT"..
That's the hard part!  After that, installation just blasts off..  I couldn't
believe how easy it was!  It took me longer to set up Win95's dial up networking
(on a freind's pc, i wont be caught dead running it..) than it took me to set
up dip!

--


 
 
 

1. Vendor wars, a religious perspective.


|>                      IBM             General motors
|>                      Microsoft       Ford
|>                      SCO             Chrysler
|>                      Linux           Jeep
|>                      NetBSD          Saturn
|>                      Interactive     Rambler
|>
|>         People, they are businesses. Doing business. Not some second
|>         coming. If you look hard enough you can find faults with *every*
|>         one of them. They all have their strong points, and they all
|>         work.
|>
|>         Can we get back to making what we are using work better and
|>         stop the 'tis 'tis not stuff for awhile?
|>
|>         Bill Gates is putting Windows on damn near every desk in the
|>         country. SCO bought Unix Ware. Deal with it.
|>
|>         Geeze..."On the net, it always September."
|>                                              J. Angus

'Nuff said!

Regards,
Dale

--
Microlite Corporation               | Dale R. Walters  
                                    | Mgr. Systems & Programming
2315 Mill Street                    |---------------------------------------
Aliquippa, PA  15001                |

Get a shot off FAST!  This upsets him long enough to let you make your
second shot PERFECT!

Lazarus Long   1916 a.d. - 4272 a.d.

2. Lack of availability of Linux in the high street

3. Word Processor Religious Wars and EZ

4. **FREE** Security Booklet "The Network Security Game" (Repost...sorry)

5. CLI, GUI, programmers, and good things (was: OS religious wars)

6. restricted ftp using chroot on AIX

7. Searching for a server... discovering religious wars.

8. Linuxconf didn't get installed with 7.1 red hat

9. NT-Unix war is a contiunation of VMS-Unix war (?)

10. "The War between the States" or "The Civil War"?

11. UNIX Wars! (was: Re: Wanted - DEC WARS)

12. NEWSFLASH: Nuclear War erupts??!! World War 3 begins??!!

13. forget editor wars, how about a SHELL war?