NIS -> NIS+ migration and login security

NIS -> NIS+ migration and login security

Post by Thorsten Kuk » Sat, 21 Nov 1998 04:00:00


: Questions:
: Is there a NIS+ client for Linux, or would I need to have (if possible) NIS+
: emulate NIS for those machines?

Look at

In the moment, you need a glibc 2.1 snapshot (glibc 2.0.102 is the latest),
but the snapshots are very stable, and glibc 2.1 should be released in a
short time. And you need a 2.1.12x Linux kernel, 2.0.x will not work.



Linux is like a Vorlon.  It is incredibly powerful, gives terse,
cryptic answers and has a lot of things going on in the background.


1. Reasonable nis security between Solaris & Linux (was Re: Is nis (yp) a security worry?

My original question was basically a "should I worry" concerning Solaris
sending encrypted passwords via nis to PC's running Linux.  The response I
got was that I should worry, e.g. about spoofing and ypcat passwd. The full
answer seems more complicated - ypcat passwd doesn't return the encrypted
passwords (rather "*" or "*NP*") for the two systems I looked at, and the
shadow file isn't in the "compatibility" list for nis+ under Solaris 2 so it
a question of yp make cobbling together the passwd and shadow file information to
make one backwards-compatible yp file.

But all this does seem to depend on the setup, and of course doesn't get me
any closer to some method of getting encrypted password to Linux clients, who
should have at least the level of security of the Solaris host from which the
passwords are kept - i.e. the /etc/shadow file is not world-readable there
so it shouldn't be readable (via ypcat or whatever) on the clients.

This *must* be something people have solved before?  I cannot run nis+ (some
of the clients, such as Linux, Sunos 4.x cannot run that), I cannot run Novell's
NDS on Solaris yet (even though Linux supports it) - besides I'm not sure that
sort of thing is what I want, and being outside the US some security options
are limited anyway.

I am scared of reducing the security of the main system with Linux satellites;
but I appreciate that "reasonable" security is always a compromise, and that
having the encrypted paswords available to Joe User is only a problem if people
choose crackable passwords anyway.  What is appropriate for the situation isn't
ultra-high security anyway, e.g. the main worry would be if academic staff's
home directories were readable (due to their encrypted passwords being distributed
to lots of computers they probably will never use) and therefore having to redo
some exam questions.  Not that I expect the students will try to break the security
but the new Linux systems are a sensitive issue and I don't want people to *fear*
them as a security loophole.

Perhaps the answer is nis 1.2 on the server, with restricted distribution of
all (? or some??) of these passwords to hosts based on IP or subnet. Again, has
anybody done this already and lived to tell the tale?
Mark Aitchison, Physics & Astronomy   \_  Phone : +64 3 3642-947 a.h. 3371-225
University of Canterbury,             </  Fax   : +64 3 3642-469  or  3642-999

#include <disclaimer.std>           (/'

2. install problem

3. NIS to NIS+ migration advice wanted

4. Specialix Si PCI and serial printer

5. NIS to NIS+ migration

6. cancel

7. NIS/NIS+ migration

8. Cant modify a remote printer on aix 4.3.2

9. NIS/Enhanced Security to LDAP migration

10. NIS migration from 4.1.1->Sol2.3

11. passwd-file -> NIS+ -> login

12. NIS/NIS+ security

13. NIS/NIS+ password security without user keypairs -- how ???