EIGRP IGRP wierdness ?

EIGRP IGRP wierdness ?

Post by michael yellan » Thu, 24 Apr 1997 04:00:00



We're having a (new) routing problem. This probably never worked
to begin with since it's never been used this way...

I think the problem is at RtrB - IGRP & EIGRP wierdness and
distribution.

Problem is remote office (& RouterA) can't ping Host198 below.
The route to 198.203.172.0 network isn't getting propagated
to RtrA.

remote office--RtrA(7000)_TR1/1--TR0_RtrB(4000)_E0--Host198

RtrA is 10.3(10)
RtrB is 10.3(10)

TR1/1 is  205.130.32.230
TR0 is 205.130.32.231
Host198 is 198.203.172.2

RtrA conf:
router eigrp 100
 redistribute static
 network 205.130.27.0
 network 205.130.28.0
 network 205.130.26.0
 network 205.130.36.0
 network 205.130.35.0
 network 205.130.39.0
 network 205.130.31.0
 network 205.130.32.0
 network 199.75.48.0
 network 204.87.11.0
 network 204.87.20.0
 network 205.130.33.0
 network 204.87.5.0
 network 204.87.6.0
 network 204.87.7.0
 network 204.87.8.0
 network 204.87.9.0
 network 204.87.10.0
 network 205.130.40.0
 no auto-summary
!
router igrp 1
 redistribute static
 network 205.130.37.0
!

RtrA ip route cache:
D    198.203.172.0 [90/297728] via 205.130.32.231, 01:04:22,
TokenRing1/1
BUT THIS WASN'T THERE UNTIL I ADDED A STATIC THEN REMOVED IT.
THE DYNAMIC STAYED THERE EVEN THOUGH IT SHOULD BE THERE I THINK.

RtrB conf:

router eigrp 100
 redistribute igrp 1
 network 146.138.0.0
 network 198.203.172.0
 network 205.130.32.0
!
router igrp 1
 network 146.138.0.0
 network 198.203.172.0
 network 205.130.32.0
 distribute-list 1 in
!
access-list 1 permit 146.138.59.0
access-list 1 permit 146.138.34.0
access-list 1 permit 205.254.154.0
access-list 1 permit 205.254.135.0
access-list 1 permit 146.138.244.0

and this in in RtrB's ip route cache:
C    198.203.172.0 is directly connected, Ethernet0

 
 
 

EIGRP IGRP wierdness ?

Post by Craig Hinkle » Fri, 25 Apr 1997 04:00:00


Michael,

I drew a mud-map of your network and as I understand it your problem is
on Router A, not router B.

I am assuming that your remote office Lan on router A is network
205.130.37.0 which is being advertised using IGRP 1.  Network
205.130.37.0 is not being re-distributed to EIGRP on Router A, so
although router A knows about Network (Host198) 198.203.172.2, Router B
does not know about network 205.130.37.0.

This could easily be confirmed by a "show ip routes" on Router B.  So
your pings to Host198 would know how to get to the destination network
BUT your Router B would not know how to get back to your remote network.

This problem could be resolved by either:
1.  Redistributing EIGRP 100 into IGRP 1 on Router A
2.  Redistributing IGRP 1 into EIGRP 100 on Router A
3.  Adding Network 205.130.37.0 to IGRP 1 on Router A
4.  Adding Network 205.130.37.0 to EIGRP 100 on Router A

The reason points 3 and 4 work is because it appears as though for this
section of your network you have almost created complete overlapping
routing domains for all of the networks connected to Router A and B that
you showed in your diagram.  Is that what you intended?

I hope this helps.

Regards,
CRAIG HINKLEY


> We're having a (new) routing problem. This probably never worked
> to begin with since it's never been used this way...

> I think the problem is at RtrB - IGRP & EIGRP wierdness and
> distribution.

> Problem is remote office (& RouterA) can't ping Host198 below.
> The route to 198.203.172.0 network isn't getting propagated
> to RtrA.

> remote office--RtrA(7000)_TR1/1--TR0_RtrB(4000)_E0--Host198

> RtrA is 10.3(10)
> RtrB is 10.3(10)

> TR1/1 is  205.130.32.230
> TR0 is 205.130.32.231
> Host198 is 198.203.172.2

> RtrA conf:
> router eigrp 100
>  redistribute static
>  network 205.130.27.0
>  network 205.130.28.0
>  network 205.130.26.0
>  network 205.130.36.0
>  network 205.130.35.0
>  network 205.130.39.0
>  network 205.130.31.0
>  network 205.130.32.0
>  network 199.75.48.0
>  network 204.87.11.0
>  network 204.87.20.0
>  network 205.130.33.0
>  network 204.87.5.0
>  network 204.87.6.0
>  network 204.87.7.0
>  network 204.87.8.0
>  network 204.87.9.0
>  network 204.87.10.0
>  network 205.130.40.0
>  no auto-summary
> !
> router igrp 1
>  redistribute static
>  network 205.130.37.0
> !

> RtrA ip route cache:
> D    198.203.172.0 [90/297728] via 205.130.32.231, 01:04:22,
> TokenRing1/1
> BUT THIS WASN'T THERE UNTIL I ADDED A STATIC THEN REMOVED IT.
> THE DYNAMIC STAYED THERE EVEN THOUGH IT SHOULD BE THERE I THINK.

> RtrB conf:

> router eigrp 100
>  redistribute igrp 1
>  network 146.138.0.0
>  network 198.203.172.0
>  network 205.130.32.0
> !
> router igrp 1
>  network 146.138.0.0
>  network 198.203.172.0
>  network 205.130.32.0
>  distribute-list 1 in
> !
> access-list 1 permit 146.138.59.0
> access-list 1 permit 146.138.34.0
> access-list 1 permit 205.254.154.0
> access-list 1 permit 205.254.135.0
> access-list 1 permit 146.138.244.0

> and this in in RtrB's ip route cache:
> C    198.203.172.0 is directly connected, Ethernet0